
With a perfect sense of irony, it appears that the spirit of the one ring has been reforged even as we spent the day watching its demise. But first, a recap:

Just to get in the spirit of things I threw together a quick display of some of my LOTR paraphenalia on the coffee table and we started (a bit late) with breakfast and Fellowship around 9:45 a.m. yesterday. Razz was in absolute bliss all day as he spent most of it bundled up in his blanket on the couch.

The day was filled with great food, including a dinner of turkey legs, green bean casserole, and red potatoes (“what’s taters, precious?”). The end of all things came at 12:11 a.m. this morning. If you’ve read my comment in my birthday post then you know that we all had a very good time. By the end I was positively buzzing with elation, and that sense of melancholy that always comes with watching these films. Thank you so much Mary and Tori for making my day so special. Actually, thank everyone for making my birthday week a complete blast. I got to put up the Christmas tree and outside Christmas lights over the weekend, went to a guy’s night out on Monday to see the new Bond film (review forthcoming), and then had yesterday’s glorious day.
As I mentioned above, the ring’s influence seems to continue as it was announced yesterday that “In a letter posted on Theonering.com., Jackson and partner Fran Walsh said an executive from New Line Cinema had called to tell them the studio was moving ahead with “The Hobbit” without him. Last week, Mark Ordesky called Ken (Kamins, Jackson’s manager) and told him that New Line would no longer be requiring our services on `The Hobbit’ and the LOTR `prequel,'” the 45-year-old New Zealand director wrote.This was a courtesy call to let us know that the studio was now actively looking to hire another filmmaker for both projects,” he said”.
As with everything else in the world this appears to be entirely about money: “The announcement came amid an ongoing dispute between Wingnut Films and New Line Cinema over the amount Jackson was paid for “The Fellowship of the Ring,” including DVD payments.While Jackson hasn’t said how much he believes he was underpaid, The New York Times last year quoted his lawyers as saying it was as much as $100 million. He is suing New Line Cinema over the shortfall.”
I am, of course, completely biased and tend to side with Peter Jackson over this. Despite his current fame and fortune he had neither when he made Fellowship and if they are truly owed money then I believe they should be paid. What makes it even more disappointing is that Mark Ordesky was instrumental in getting the LOTR films made in the first place and he is all over the documentaries for the three films sharing how magical the experience of making them was. Despite how special the making of that film was, and one trip through the documentaries will drive that point home, its sad to see this taint being put on that experience.
Its not that another director/writer can’t do a good job with the Hobbit, I am sure there are others out there with the same passion for the story that Peter, Philippa, and Fran have, but this film should have the look, feel, and love for the material that the trilogy has and I think this will be hard to accomplish without that team. I hope New Line and PJ somehow can work out their differences enough to allow WETA to do all the effects, etc. I am disappointed by this, as I will be disappointed if Ian Holm isn’t the one chosen to be Bilbo. Why do so many good things have to be tainted by selfishness and greed?
You can read Peter Jackson’s statement about this here (scroll down to Nov. 20th post).
Despite this I had a wonderful birthday and thank you all again for the well wishes, they are appreciated more than you may know. Have a terrific Thanksgiving weekend everyone!
I, too, was disappointed to hear about The Hobbit…but I’m still holding a bit of hope that this all will blow over and things will come to a positive ending!
Love your bookend, and Razz looks SO comfy!
He was comfy…it was quite comical to watch him doze all day.
I got that bookend when Return of the King Ext. Edition came out…it was cool enough that I thought it was worth it. I wish now that I had gotten the one with the Argonath when I bought Fellowship of the Ring.
Carl, your spirit is an ever present source of joy to those who read your blog, and I’m sure to those who know you more intimately. I am entranced with your imagination, and with the sense of wonder you face life. You make me smile, you make me think, you find the extraordinary in the mundane.
Bonne Anniversaire: a truly Happy, Happy Birthday to you.
I think New Line is about to piss in their whiskey, as Ben Franklin would say. LOTR fans are the most loyal of ANY fans, and they/we have adopted Peter Jackson as the ONE director for the franchise. Any Tolkein-themed movie made without his involvement is going to go down. Hard.
I’m glad you had a wonderful day and I think Wayne is correct. LOTR fans will not be
quick to embrace another director on the Hobbit. Although maybe the SW prequels
would have been better without Lucas at the helm. 🙂
I don’t know if you’ll read this or if it’s too far down, but I have a question:
Are the extended editions of the LOTR films better than the non-extended? I want to buy my own copies of the DVDs, and I don’t know what edition to get, or anyone to ask who has watched both.
I’ve only seen the theatrical cuts (and read the book), but I love them…
The extended editions are far and away better than the theatrical versions in my opinion. Actually though you can go the easy route and get the very newest versions that are out. They have both the extended edition and theatrical editions. They are these ones.
I love the series and they made serious bank of the trilogy, I tend to agreee with you, if he feels underpaid, he most likely is. I don’t think the films would be what they are without his influence. Makes me not look forward to The Hobbit at all.
Someone posted the other day that it looks like things may work out for him to be involved in it…that will be my continual hope.