Category Archives: Book Reviews

In which the reader shares his thoughts on the books that possess his imagination throughout the year.

Dune Group Read, Round 2




My father once told me that respect for the truth comes close to being the basis for all morality. “Something cannot emerge from nothing,” he said. This is profound thinking if you understand how unstable “the truth” can be.

~from “Conversations with Muad’Dib” by the Princess Irulan






A Duke is betrayed. The betrayer is silenced. And in the aftermath a boy and his mother set out into a barren desert wilderness, perhaps in fulfillment of an ancient prophecy.

It is Saturday, and that means it is time for more conversation about Frank Herbert’s masterwork, Dune. This past week the group read covered Book Two: Muad’Dib, the gripping middle section of this unfolding drama. I cannot help but recall the words of Poe–

That the play is the tragedy “Man,”
And its hero the Conqueror Worm.

Andrea (Little Red Reviewer) took on the challenge of coming up with this week’s discussion questions. Thank you Andrea! She sent out a list of questions giving responders the option of answering all or just some of the questions. Below the jump you will find my reflections as well as our good friend Mr. Linky, who will guide you to the discussions of the other respondents.

Once again I feel obligated to warn you that spoilers are present in the Q&A portion of these posts. And once again I would like to encourage discussion from anyone who would like to participate, not just those who are currently a part of this group read.

And now, Book Two.

Continue reading Dune Group Read, Round 2 →

Dune Group Read, Round 1

“A beginning is the time for taking the most delicate care that the balances are correct. This every sister of the Bene Gesserit knows. To begin your study of the life of Muad’Dib, then take care that you first place him in his time: born in the 57th year of the Padishah Emperor, Shaddam IV. And take the most special care that you locate Muad’Dib in his place: the planet Arrakis. Do not be deceived by the fact that he was born on Caladan and lived his first fifteen years there. Arrakis, the planet known as Dune, is forever his place.”

~from Manual of Muad’Dib by the Princess Irulan


Dune.

Like Ahab’s whale this heralded science fiction classic has eluded me for years. Looked at more honestly I am Moby Dick, and thanks to the assistance of a crew of fellow readers, Dune has finally landed me.

The first week of July has passed and with it our group reading of the first part (Book 1: Dune) of Herbert’s classic. It was my honor to ask the questions for this first section, my answers of which you will find after the jump. For those either not participating in the group read or those who have not yet completed this first section, I will warn you that the answers to the following questions will most likely contain spoilers.

If any of you have read Dune but are not participating in the group read, please feel free to answer any or all of these questions either in the comments here on my site or on the site of any of the other participants. At the end of this post you will find links to the Q&A posts of the other participants.

I would ask that you do not reveal anything that happens later in the book, past this first section, as several of us have not read the book before. Thank you.

If for some reason you get behind in the reading, please keep on going at your pace and answer the questions when you can.

Okay, here we go:

Continue reading Dune Group Read, Round 1 →

The Very Best of Charles de Lint







“We’re all made of stories. When they finally put us underground, the stories are what will go on. Not forever, perhaps, but for a time. It’s a kind of immortality, I suppose, bounded by limits, it’s true, but then so’s everything.”
— Charles de Lint







Those of you following along over the course of the last few months will recall that Kailana and I were conducting a buddy read of The Very Best of Charles de Lint. We discussed the stories contained within it in groups of threes on our respective sites by taking turns asking and answering questions about the stories. Now that we’ve come to the end we have decided to do an overall review of the book and this experience by asking a series of back and forth questions. The first 5 questions are answered on Kailana’s site. I would ask that you start over there before continuing on with these questions and answers, and we would both love to have your comments for the various parts of the discussion on our respective sites.

As always, thanks for your input and please jump in on the conversation.

Continue reading The Very Best of Charles de Lint →

Just a Geek ~Wil Wheaton


Just a Geek ~Wil Wheaton

–published 2004
–O-Reilly Media
–269 pages
–8/10

“…the plain truth is that this book is really for any kind of nerd or geek out there and as such is one I can recommend without reservation. It is a quick, entertaining and satisfying read that has me looking to track down the rest of Wil Wheaton’s books…this was a real treat.”

~Me!, from This Very Review


Before getting into the meat of this review please allow me a moment of self-disclosure.

Confession:   I hated Wesley Crusher.

Realization:   I am not sure I ever really had the right to.

Let me explain. By my own personal definition I am not a “fan” of Star Trek: The Next Generation. The show began in 1987, the year I graduated from high school. I had been a fan of the original series since early childhood and I remember being vaguely annoyed that “they” were going to tread on my memories by bringing Star Trek back without James Tiberius Kirk at the helm of the U.S.S. Enterprise. Beyond that original annoyance I did not give it much thought. I was finishing up one chapter of my life and opening the book on the next. I was moving to another state to go to college. And the majority of the last half of 1987 I was homesick, pretty overwhelmed with my first year of college, and busy. In 1988 I began dating the girl who would a year later become my wife. Again, I was very busy and television was not a priority.

Wil Wheaton was a cast member from its inception through its first 4 seasons. I didn’t get around to finally watching The Next Generation in earnest until its final 3 seasons, by which point Wesley Crusher was gone. Yes, I saw him on the occasional syndicated episode or one I may have caught now and again on its original run. And yes I did not like what I saw of the character. But I am not a fan of The Next Generation and one of many realizations I came to when reading this solid and entertaining book was while my opinion may be legitimate, the grounds for my hatred of Wesley Crusher quite possibly were not.

More important, Wil Wheaton is not Wesley Crusher.

Continue reading Just a Geek ~Wil Wheaton →

Anya’s Ghost ~Vera Brosgol

Anya’s Ghost ~Vera Brosgol

–published 2011
–First Second Books
–221 pages
–9/10

Navigating the tumultuous waters of adolescence is difficult enough in a typical American high school. For Russian-born Anya Borzakovskaya those difficulties are compounded by a last name and a culture that she works hard to distance herself from. What successes she has gained in the battle to “fit in” are put in daily peril by body image issues, poor school performance, and the presence of another Russian student, Dima, a prototypical nerd with a thick Russian accent who regularly tries to befriend her. One day when familial and school obligations threaten to overwhelm her, Anya decides to take a walk in the park, wherein she discovers, quite by accident, an old well. Things go from bad to worse when she discovers the bones of the last person to stumble across the well and with them, a ghost.

In her debut book, Anya’s Ghost, author/artist Vera Brosgol combines clean lines and subtle retro-styling with tight prose to tell a compelling and sometimes mysterious tale about a young girl’s journey towards becoming herself.

Continue reading Anya’s Ghost ~Vera Brosgol →